Thursday, July 30, 2015

What's the Biggest Problem?

I’m getting worried that the LUEE folks will think I’m stalking them, so it’s high time I talked about another podcast. That’s right, I’m seeing other podcasts. Sorry you had to find out this way.

There’s this show called Geeks Without God, from three Minneapolis-based improv comics. They have a segment where at the end of every interview they ask each guest the same five questions. This month they rolled out a new series of questions. One of them is particularly interesting: “Say Religion is gone.  What is the biggest problem that now faces humanity?”

They have put this question to three guests so far. This week, Joseph Scrimshaw answered either guns or internet comments. Last week Miranda Richards answered the power vacuum that would develop, and the need to make sure that with all the leaders gone, the world wasn’t just handed over to assholes.

The first guest to get this question was Rebecca Watson, three weeks ago. She objected to the premise, because the wording of the question implies that religion is the biggest problem right now. When pressed she answered that income inequality is the biggest problem right now and would continue be the biggest problem with religion gone… that religion can worsen income inequality, but that income inequality can worsen religion to a much greater extent.

Like Rebecca, I think the premise could use some serious examining. It’s fairly well established that nonreligious people are more ethical than religious people. They are generally much less racist and sexist and homophobic and such, and they are much less likely to commit crimes. But it’s very difficult to figure out if that correlation means causation, and if so which is the cause.

Heina Dadabhoy did a very good takedown of the prison statistics. It’s true that in the United States the nonreligious are much less likely to be in prison, perhaps less than a twentieth as likely… but they are also better educated, better employed, wealthier, and whiter. That takes care of most or all of the distinction.

There’s a similar problem on the societal level. Sure, those countries with less religion are much better places to live, that’s indisputable. Phil Zuckerman wrote a great book on it, Society Without God. But the causation might go the other way. Zuckerman proposed - and was certainly not the first to do so - that religion flourishes in societies that aren’t nice places to live. That religious communities are a vital part of the social safety net when in places where governments fail. That the afterlife becomes valuable when life is cheap.

It’s been a few years since I’ve read his book, but from what I remember I think he also proposed that inequality contributed more than absolute wealth. This explains of the highly religious United States, which is relatively wealthy but has high concentration of wealth… some people are very very rich, but there is much more poverty than in many poorer countries.

That leads right to Rebecca’s answer… that the main problem in the world today is income inequality. If religion vanished overnight, the causes of religion would still be there. Something would take its place. People fighting for scraps would find new divisions to kill for. People desperate for escape would find new fairy tales to tell themselves. Leaders trying to control the populace would find new justifications for arbitrary rules.

I’m not sure it’s the best answer, though… it’s hard to disagree with Rebecca, but can anything really top internet comments for pure evil?

Saturday, July 25, 2015

Welfare, Justice, and Laffing

I’ve been doing a little canvassing for the NDP, and in that capacity I’ve gotten in more political discussions than I’ve ever had in my life… even though those discussions generally take up too much time to be worthwhile. I’ve had some trouble understanding the conservatives around here, because I give them the benefit of the doubt and assume they understand the consequences of their positions. If they aren’t ignorant, they must have some motivation, right? But it can be tough to figure out their motivations.

So I’ve been trying to figure out some of the underlying differences between conservatives and liberals, stuff that goes deeper than the issues of the day. Robert Altemeyer’s work was very helpful in showing the authoritarian / anti-authoritarian split, but I figure there must be other causes as well. After all, there was a time when there were authoritarian left-wing regimes, albeit not recently enough for me to remember them.

I think one of the big psychological impulses underlying conservatism these days is probably a drive to prevent cheating a punish cheaters. This must be behind the drive to limit welfare, and especially to drug test welfare recipients… conservatives will tolerate an inefficient and wasteful system if is helps prevent anybody from cheating the system, from becoming a “welfare queen”.

It’s probably similar with the justice system. Here there’s the liberal impulse: “better ten guilty men go free than one innocent suffer”. And there’s an opposing conservative impulse, which is best seen when dealing with despised underclasses like racial or religious minorities: better to lock them all up than risk one going free. Or better to kill them all and let God sort them out.

I suspect that optimally efficient solutions could be found for both of these, a level of scrutiny which will produce some false positives and some false negatives. That solution need not be the average of the liberal and conservative ideals, though, nor even between those ideals at all. I’m reminded of the Laffer Curve idea for optimum tax rates, which usual predicts that the most efficient tax rates are 60 to 80%, far above what even the crunchiest lefties want in this country.

There could be some dispute choosing the best goal to aim for, though. In the example of the tax rates, the 60-80% is the rate to maximize tax collection, and thus the size of the government. Other optimum rates can be found to maximize the size of the private sector (not zero, but certainly not 70%) or to maximize the size of the economy as a whole.

I guess this brings it around to those motivations. If someone is proposing a justice system that isn’t calibrated right to give the lowest crime rate, what is it calibrated for? What is the real goal?

This is getting perilously close to me needing to read a whole stack of new books. I’m not sure when I’ll find the time.

KevinMD Strikes Again

I'm going to get perilously close to talking about something that I actually know a thing or two about. I'll try not to make a habit of this.

I read an article today on KevinMD, 10 things you might not know about the emergency department. I wasn’t too happy with it, mostly for the same reasons I brought up back in April: High-minded rhetoric about the ER being inappropriate for certain medical complaints overlooks the fact that it’s the only medical service available to many people. Saying that the ER isn’t the best place to treat tooth pain is all well and good, but Dentists aren’t free. If that tooth ends of breaking or rotting, guess what, the ER will deal with it. It will just be ten times more expensive by then.

One part that jumped out at me was the section on not trusting patients… every woman gets a pregnancy test, regardless of what she says about her sexual activity. Just this morning I saw a post somewhere - I’m not sure who wrote it, or even what site I saw it on - saying how empowering it had been to get a CT exam without having a pregnancy test first. How wonderful it was to have the doctor trust her, even just a little bit.

I’m not saying pregnancy tests aren’t a good idea, to help diagnose abdominal pain, or before giving treatments that are dangerous for pregnant women. But just doing the test on every woman who walks through the front doors is excessive.

There’s a complaint about patients using their phones… when I went to the ER last month, I packed a phone, a charger, a spare battery, and ebook reader, and a tablet. I knew I was in for a wait.

Oh, yeah, the article also says not to complain about the wait. Well, if you aren’t allowing any food, water, or distractions…

This isn’t the only problematic article on KevinMD recently. There was also a video a couple days ago, complaining about having to treat obese patients. I didn’t see it, it was pulled as soon as there was a public outcry. And there was an article on July 7 telling about how a surgeon cut a patient’s vena cava in order to teach a student how to deal with emergencies. This was presented as a valuable lesson, not an attempted murder. That article was pulled as well, not because it described a horrific crime, but because it couldn’t be verified. Something tells me the author wasn’t eager to give out incriminating info just to prove it happened.

It doesn’t surprise me that some doctors have this kind of contempt for their patients, though I am surprised they are so eager to admit it publically. Maybe everyone involved in medicine should be the patient now and then… if only to see how long they last without a bed and a book.

Wednesday, July 22, 2015

Vast Majority Vaccinated

Can we all just agree not to consider the “vast majority” vaccinated unless it reaches herd immunity? This is a very hopeful and optimistic article, but the news it presents is not actually all that good. The vaccination rates are sufficient to protect most people, but most is a pretty low bar when it comes to infectious disease.

91% immunized against polio is enough to keep it from spreading. But 72% is not enough for HPV. And 89% is not enough for measles, not nearly enough. The required threshold for measles might be as high as 94%. And that’s just to prevent spreading throughout the whole population, not for prevent local outbreaks. Unvaccinated people tend to associate with each other… it doesn’t help for even 99% of the population to have immunity if all the vulnerable people live in the same town or go to the same school.

There are many people who simply can’t be vaccinated, because they are too young, or too old, or they have compromised immune systems, or they are immunosuppressed. The measles fatality in Washington this year was immunosuppressed.

89% sounds like a high number when you first hear it. But that still means 11% are being negligent. It still means the deaths of infants and cancer patients. If 11% of the population were attacking transplant recipients with thrown rocks instead of viruses, would that be low enough?

Monday, July 20, 2015

I Had To Pass To Earn It For You

There’s a meme going around facebook, about drug-testing for welfare recipients. I saw it yesterday and immediately blocked it, but today I’m still angry enough that I figured I should write about it. Unfortunately, I can’t find it again… I don’t know if there’s a way for Facebook users to find a list of content they’ve blocked.


Even more unfortunately, I could find lots of similar images, because the sentiment is so common that it gets recirculated frequently.





There’s a few different arguments being made here… practicality, that money can be saved by not paying welfare to those who test positive. Fairness, that workers have to be drug tested so everyone should be. A free will argument, that addicts can stop using drugs on a whim when it becomes inconvenient to them. And finally retribution, that people who use drugs should be punished with destitution, starvation, and death.


That’s a lot to unpack, but I’ll start with the easy one. Welfare drug testing is not practical, because it costs far more to conduct the drug testing than is saved by cancelling the benefits to those few who test positive. This is mostly because of the low baseline rates of drug use, even lower in the welfare population than the general population. This makes sense, right? Drugs cost money. It should not be a surprise.


Just like I said yesterday, it’s great when you can avoid a difficult ethical dilemma because the premises are unsound.


On to the fairness issue. The problem with this is that two wrongs don’t make a right. Your employer treats you like crap, and you think the solution is to drag other people down to your level? There are other options. Get a better employer, a better contract, a better lawyer, or a better union. You shouldn’t have to put up with that kind of treatment. I don’t get routinely or randomly drug tested, and I have the constant danger of killing people with a moment’s inattention.


Can people stop? Some illegal drugs aren’t significantly addictive, like marijuana, mushrooms, or ecstasy. With these, you could very well reduce usage by preventing welfare payments. But the problem arises that less addictive drugs are also the least harmful. Those drugs which are the most debilitating, the most harmful, the most expensive to treat, these are the drugs which people would be unable to stop using upon request. In other words, if welfare drug testing worked to reduce drug usage, it would only reduce the use of those drugs that we really shouldn’t care if people use or not.


Retribution… well, that one’s harder to argue with. If someone thinks that addicts ought to starve to death I’m not going to convince them otherwise in a single essay. That shows either a lack of empathy so severe as to be considered sociopathy, or a level of ignorance so severe as to require years of education. Either one, I think, would be better treated by experts than by me.

I’m just here to keep people who ought to know better from clicking Like and Share without thinking about what that actually means.

Sunday, July 19, 2015

Avoiding Ethical Dilemmas the Easy Way

There was a new episode of LUEE last week… I know it seems like it hasn’t been long enough since I commented on their work, but that’s because my last post was nearly a month late. Like 29 days and 22 hours late.

This month they were talking about the judicial system. Can I just say for starters how much fun it is to have people say things I agree with, backed up by multivariate statistical analysis? So much better than just shouting your opinions louder and louder, like I normally do.

They talked a bit about gun control, and I think they missed the mark a little. Don’t get me wrong, I agree with them here too. But it’s not enough to say that gun control means fewer gun homicides and gun suicides. The gun nuts have heard that before, and there’s an easy comeback that goes back at least to Archie Bunker: You’d prefer if people were stabbed?

Now, those gun deaths don’t all get replaced with other deaths. You know it, I know it. But it can’t just go unsaid. But there’s enough people intentionally confusing the issue that you need to talk about all-cause mortality, even if only briefly.

On to funner things. Racial profiling doesn’t work. Isn’t that great? It’s so convenient when you can completely avoid a difficult ethical dilemma because the basic premises are unsound.

There’s a new panelist (or very rarely recurring), Brendan. He was talking about prison abolition, focusing mainly on the US. I tend to agree with most of what he was saying, but I don’t think the case has been made for abolishing prisons in all cases. And in his defence, he admits there aren’t any easy answers for “what about the murderers”.

I think there’s a lot to be said for adjusting the baseline, though. In Canada the default rate of imprisonment is only a fifth that of the US, with no ill effects. I’m lefty-progressive enough to think that the Canadian prison rate could stand to drop as well, but if you take it as it is that still leaves room to abolish 80% of American prisons. Or better yet, abolish half of prisons and release 80% of prisoners, so simultaneously fix the overcrowding problem.

Not only is it nice to avoid difficult ethical dilemmas when the premises are unsound, it’s also really nice when you can put them off because there’s a lot of fixing to be done before you even get close to encountering that dilemma.

Anyway, great show. But I think I now have three books I have to read, which I don’t know that I have time for. I’ll see how it goes.

Saturday, July 18, 2015

Salute



I’m seeing a lot of hubbub about the Queen being taught the Nazi salute by her uncle. The news sites have screwed this one up pretty badly, and I hate to see that much ignorance on display.

Now I’m not normally one to defend the monarchy... you’re not going to make me defend them, are you? It’s just not fair. See, the british royals are terrible people who do terrible things in terrible ways for terrible reasons. But they aren’t Nazis. Well, not necessarily, not based on this flimsy evidence at any rate.

The pictures are from 1933. As it turns out, all sorts of people used that salute back then. Before it was the Nazi salute it was the Fascist salute. 


Before that, it was used by Americans in the pledge of allegiance.


And way, way before that, it was the Roman salute.


About the only thing these groups all have common is Nationalism, and some right wing anti-socialism. And it’s not exactly news that the British royals are Nationalists. Were you shocked? I wasn’t shocked.

So in conclusion, something something doomed to repeat it. Don’t be doomed. And don't write news articles based on The Sun except to point and laugh. And if you have to point and laugh maybe don't point with your whole hand.